MAD MEN: Don Draper’s “Mark” of Childhood Trauma. Fears & Lies

It’s not only “Belle Jolie lipstick – (that) Mark (s) Your Man.” No. The real mark is childhood trauma. That’s exactly what marks Don Draper. He lives with it every day. Season 1, Episode 8, The Hobo Code, makes his trauma even clearer. No mother’s kiss, no father’s warmth, no acceptance, no love. So how can he trust anything or anyone? Hurt and shame left Don with many fears. He ran. He had to kill his childhood self. And he’s been living a lie ever since. But is the Hobo’s code, which marked his childhood home, “A dishonest man lives here,” who Don is? 

Fear is The Toll of Living a Lie 

Yes, Don Draper lives a lie. But as we’ll find out, he isn’t his father. His lie isn’t cruelty. It’s survival. Yet living a lie takes a toll: the constant fear of being “found out.” You might drown out that fear with alcohol or affairs, as Don does. But the fear lingers. It prods. It makes your hands shake, no matter how hard you try to keep your cool and pretend to be someone you’re not. 

So that’s where we find Don (Jon Hamm), called into the Sterling Cooper office. His fear is even worse because only Mr. Cooper wants to meet with him. Roger Sterling (John Slattery) is his friend. Bertram Cooper (Robert Morse) intimidates him. As he walks in, Don is visibly anxious. His hands shake. He steadies himself, but he still looks nervous. Has he done something wrong? Is he being fired? Or, as much as he tries to be good, is he being called out as he was as a child? 

What could Cooper want with him? Don is always worried about not being good enough, being wrong, being yelled at, and being shamed. These are signs of his trauma. Instead, Mr. Cooper hands him a $2500 check, a bonus for his work. What?! How could that be? He expects hurt, not a reward. And besides, it’s a lot of money in those days. Even more shocking, Mr. Cooper, being really friendly, sidles up to him and asks whether he knows about Ayn Rand and her book, Atlas Shrugged. Even stranger, Cooper believes he and Don are the same. Could Don be that good?

 But it’s a little different. Mr. Cooper puts it this way: “We are alike. By that I mean, you are a productive and reasonable man; in the end, completely self-interested. It’s strength. We are different, unsentimental about all the people who depend on our hard work.” Cooper sees something in Don that Don is trying to hide, both who Don is and who he’s not. Don is a mixed bag. Beneath all his lies, he actually cares about people. But he’s too scared to show it. He runs from his soft feelings and from settling into love. Don has had to be out for himself ...

“Out for Yourself:” A Trauma Defense 

When you’ve been alone your whole life, enduring abuse and humiliation as a child, you have to be “out for yourself.” No one else is there to count on. You’re terrified. You find ways to survive. So, unsentimental about people? Well, that’s not exactly Don. He’s numbed himself. He’s not like Cooper. Sure, Don is out for himself in certain ways, managing his trauma and pretending to be someone else so he can like himself (at least a little bit). And he does hurt people. He hurts his wife and his children. We barely know Betty (January Jones), the wife, yet. But deep down, this isn’t really who Don is, nor who he wants to be. Hurting people is a result of his defenses against his trauma. His drinking and sexual addiction come straight out of being unwanted as a child. He needs to be desired. He doesn’t set out to hurt people. He lives in a certain kind of denial. Drinking and sex are numbing compulsions: the demons of his trauma that make him do these things.

Yes, Don’s had to be self-focused. No one looked out for him. No one cared. His flashback to the hobo makes that loud and clear. He had to take whatever he could. For Don, it’s not narcissism, as it is for Cooper. It’s not a lack of care for others. It’s pure, unadulterated survival. Ultimately, Don has to face the music. He has to confront where he came from and accept that it wasn’t his fault. But right now, he’s struggling. He’s scared. He carries deep guilt. So, no, when Cooper calls him in, he doesn't expect praise. Not at all. He never got any praise as a child. He was only reprimanded and told that everything about him was bad. Bad. That’s what Don lives with ...

The “Mark” of Never Feeling Wanted 

So here we are with the “Belle Jolie lipstick - Mark Your Man” pitch. Don turns the whole idea of men owning women on its head. (Well, really, it was Peggy’s idea, but women don’t get much credit.) We also know Don has a difficult relationship with women. He was controlled by his stepmom’s cruelty, her rejection, and the shame he felt for being who he was (but really wasn’t). He’s tried and tried his whole life to be wanted, and he never feels he is or will be. No. Not really. 

And when someone doesn’t want him, Don’s more than ready to walk out. To find someone else. The Belle Jolie owners initially reject his pitch. They say they see only one lipstick in the drawing and that women want lots and lots of colors. Don says, “It’s OK to call it a day, gentlemen. Thank you for your time. You’re a non-believer.” Don won’t waste any more of his life on someone who doesn’t believe in him or take him seriously. That’s his childhood trauma. No more of that.

Well, they don’t understand why he won’t listen to them. (We get it, though. Don has no more time for people like this.) “It means you’ve already tried your plan and you’re #4. You enlist my expertise, then reject it to keep going the way you’ve been going. I’m not interested in that ... I’m not here to tell you about Jesus. You already know about Jesus. He lives in your heart, or he doesn’t. Every woman wants choices, but in the end, none wants to be one of 100 in a box. She’s unique. She makes the choices, and she’s chosen him. She wants to tell the world he’s mine. He belongs to me, not you. She marks her man with her lips. He is her possession. You’ve given every girl who wears your lipstick total ownership.” The Belle Jolie executive says, “Sit down.” Don won’t be owned by anyone ever again: “Not until I know you’re not wasting my time.” 

The executive says again, “Sit down.” Don has done it. He knows, in a shattering way, what it means to be someone’s possession. He knows how to turn that on its head. At least he can try. Don refuses to feel unwanted, but does he ever succeed?

His trauma follows him everywhere.

Triggers: What Shaped Don Draper?

A traumatic memory can take over at any time. You can’t control what triggers it. No matter how hard Don tries to “forget,” his success, drinking, and running away don’t really protect him. You never know when something unexpected will take you right back there. Right back to a painful memory that shaped you. He tries to shake off the unsettling fear and anxiety about Cooper and the Belle Jolie account, but drinking isn’t enough. Maybe escaping to Paris on a romantic fantasy with Midge might help? So now Don’s at Midge’s door, waving the $2500 check and telling her they’re going to Paris. But Midge isn’t one to be told what to do. And she’s not a woman who’s marked Don as her man. She’s a free-spirited Bohemian with a lot of druggie friends at her place.

Midge says, “No.” She has plans. Her plans are to party with her friends. Don already turned around one big “No” that day, and he expects to do it again. He hangs around, but he’s as much a fish out of water as he was as a kid. That feeling sets him up for a trigger. When one of Midge’s friends says he just realized there is no music, just the scratch, scratch, scratch of the needle, Don has a flashback. To the hobo. At home with his abusive, cruel father and stepmother, digging, digging, digging in the dirt, with the same noise as the scratch, scratch, scratch…

Don is back in the past. He’s a little kid. He’s Dick Whitman, his real name. He’s back where he never wants to be again, remembering: A hobo approaches and asks for a meal; he’ll work for it. Dick’s father, Archie (Joseph Culp), is frustrated, curt, and cruel. He says, “No Christians here anymore. Work will feed your soul, but no more work here for the day.” The hobo asks, “Come back tomorrow?” Don’s stepmother feels guilty, though she doesn't seem to care how she treats her little stepson, who tries to be quiet, good, and out of the way, always doing what he’s told. 

Yes, Abigail Whitman (Brynn Horrocks) sees herself as a good Christian woman (and we wonder why, as her unthinkable cruelty toward Dick unfolds alongside Don’s trauma. People can live with mind-boggling projection and denial). She says, “Nonsense: you’ll stay with us and eat with us and work tomorrow. I will have to boil those clothes, though, if you’re going to sit at my table.” She yells (nicer to the hobo than to Dick): “Dick Whitman! Stop digging holes; build a fire under the cauldron.” The hobo says, “Hiya, kid.” She yells, “What did I say to you?” Dick lives in a state of distraction, a trauma defense. He doesn’t want to be there. He doesn’t want to be who he is. The hobo says, “Reminds me of myself.” Abigail replies, “That doesn’t surprise me at all.”

She makes Dick feel like a loser. He can’t fathom anyone, even a hobo, being nice to him. No wonder he’s anxious, worried about failing in Cooper’s eyes. It’s because of what he endures beneath his façade. The way he was made to feel as a child still eats at him. Despite his lies, he’s still that little boy.

The Mark of Having No Love 

Dick believes he must be bad. He believes it's all his fault that he's treated the way he is. He doesn’t know what he’s done. He tries to be good. As good as he tries to be at Sterling Cooper, as Don Draper, as a star ad man. But yes, his past follows him everywhere. Children don’t have any other way to see it, not until someone else comes along. And sometimes that’s not enough.

He’s a smart boy. Dick Whitman. We know that. We see how smart Don is. How observant. He watches everything. He watches how the hobo is treated and how the hobo talks to Dick. He’s kind. Even though Dick can’t understand it, it doesn’t feel unwelcome. The hobo has good manners. But Archie humiliates him because that’s who Dick’s dad is: “New York? That’s how you took to being on the bum so easy ... I bet you don’t know which end of a weed to pull.  Are you a communist?” “No.” Abigail says, “They are souls, but they can’t be saved.” She’s harsh and cold.

Dick sits very, very quietly and listens. Can he be saved? She makes him feel like he’s worth nothing. She’s hard as a rock. But she takes out a coin and places it on the table next to the hobo. Archie takes it back. "Tomorrow, when you finish some work.”

Flashing between past and present (at Midge’s), just as out of place as he was as a child, Don remembers coming in to give the hobo some blankets. The hobo is rolling a cigarette: “Smoke?” Dick answers, “No.” The hobo says, “Oh, he speaks.” Dick goes on, “I’m supposed to tell you to say your prayers.” “Praying won’t help you from this place, kid. Best keep your mind on your mother. She’ll probably look after you.” Dick tells him, “She ain’t my mama. Ain’t you heard? I’m a whore-child ... You don’t talk like a bum.” “I’m not. I’m a gentleman of the rails; for me, every day is brand new. Every day is a brand-new place, brand-new people.” Dick says, “So... you got no home? That’s sad.” Dick knows that kind of sadness… always being on the outside of love.

The Hobo Code: Maybe It’s Not His Fault 

One of the worst things about being unwanted as a child is the lack of love. It leaves its mark. It leaves you hungry and scared. Don’s affairs are complicated. He doesn’t know love. Doesn’t believe in it. Doesn’t trust it. But he looks for it the only way he can ... in women he can’t be with. In women who aren’t a threat. In women who desire him yet show him love’s absence. But the hobo’s code will begin to plant a seed, a seed long in the making; maybe it’s not his fault.

Back in the present, Don takes a Polaroid of Midge. When he develops it, he knows Midge and the man she’s leaning against are in love. Midge shrugs it off. “That’s ridiculous.” But Don advertises love every day. He knows what it looks like. Yet he’s always on the outside. He was on the outside as a child, and he keeps himself there. It's a survival tactic. It’s safer that way. But Don’s not without longings. He wants to run off with Midge on a romantic adventure and pretend it’s love. But he was never part of love. Then or now. (The hobo saw that...)

Don holds out the check to Midge. "Paris, now, let’s go." “Don, I can’t.” She looks sad, and so does he. Don takes the check, signs it over to her, slips it into her bra, and tells her, “Buy yourself a car.” He looks at the door, as forlorn as he was as a little boy.

The Bohemians' taunts ring in his ears: “Look at you, satisfied, dreaming up jingles about snowflakes and spot remover, telling yourself you’re free; you make the lie; you invent want.” Don retorts, “I hate to break it to you, but there is no big lie ... the universe is indifferent.” Don knows about indifference. About too much wanting. About dishonesty. The hobo taught him the code. But is the dishonest way Don has had to live who he really is? Well, he isn’t his father ...

Does Don’s Father Mark Him ...? 

The hobo. He’s a man who knows what it’s like to escape a life he couldn’t stand. He sees a trapped, lonely boy who can’t yet escape. But maybe he can plant a seed. At least he can try. And he did... He tells Dick: “Here. You’re an honorary (hobo); this is how we talk to each other. On the front gate of every house, there’s a mark; it’s a code. That’s a pie. It means the food here is good... This one means a dishonest man lives here... Don’t be scared, kid; you ain’t a man yet...”

Don flashes back to watching the hobo leave, graciously thanking his father for letting him stay. Don’s heartless dad reaches into his pocket. The hobo expects the money he was promised for his work. Instead, Archie arrogantly takes out a cigarette, lights it, and tells the hobo, disdainfully, “Be on your way already." Dick watches, peeling an apple. The hobo walks away. Dick runs after him, but he’s already gone. Dick looks under a tree’s leaves. As the hobo said, he carved a mark. The mark reads: “A dishonest man lives here.” That’s the dad Dick has. It haunts him now.

A traumatic childhood marks the man. Yes, Don lies and feels lonely among people who don’t know him. He may be dishonest, but he’s not his father. He’s conflicted. He runs away. He can’t feel safe in marriage. He doesn’t believe he can be loved. As he leaves Midge, he’s alone. He can't turn to Betty. But as much as he can, he loves his children, Bobby and Sally. At home, he goes into their room and wakes Bobby. “SHHHH, your sister is sleeping. Ask me anything.” “Why do lightning bugs light up?” Don looks sad and says, “I don’t know, but I will never lie to you.” He doesn’t want to be his dad... but his doubts haunt him: what does it mean to love? 

How to Love When You Had None...? 

Don doesn’t know about lightning bugs. He never lit up a room as a child. No smile ever said, “I love you, you’re so special.” So nothing and no one can light him up, either. He can’t let his guard down. He scans every room for a frown. He drinks away the worry that warns, “You’re no good.” He lives the lie of “a better man,” never feeling, ever, that Dick Whitman could measure up. 

So ... Love? That’s a difficult question.

It’s hard to love when you had none as a child. And if you do feel love, you don’t trust it. You can’t. You’re scared. You don’t believe you’ll ever get loved back.

So ... Yes, Don has to live his lies every day. He’s a dishonest man who hates himself for it. And what’s the worst lie of all? He’s terrified of becoming his father, so he can’t show up for his own kids. Kids he wants to love. Kids he does love. Kids who don’t even know him. Now that we know a little about Don’s past, we watch him struggle. At Sterling Cooper, he opens a door: “Don Draper.” We know it isn’t who he really is.

But Don can’t shed his cover. No. Not quite yet.

Next
Next

MAD MEN: What Happens When You Don’t Strike It Lucky as a Child